Chapter 55: The Slave Chieftain's Inferiority Complex

The Great Ming: Tianqi Era Record of Instructions 2230 words 2026-03-24 19:35:36

That evening, he summoned the commanders of regimental rank and above to a meeting.

"The Jianzhou Jurchens will never allow Haizhou to be lost," he said. "They will spare no effort to recapture it. Therefore, I have two proposals. First, we order all troops in Gaizhou to relocate to Haizhou, using this city as a stronghold to wear down the Jianzhou forces. Second, we have a portion of the Gaizhou garrison come to cover our gradual retreat, using Gaizhou as our base to maneuver against the Jianzhou army. Each plan has its own merits and drawbacks. I cannot make up my mind, so let us discuss them together."

Du Guangting spoke up eagerly, "Haizhou has ample provisions, and the Jianzhou are poor at siege warfare. We can turn this city into a bloody meat grinder and bleed the Jianzhou dry right here!"

Sun Fumin, the commander of the artillery battalion, looked at the map and said, "Haizhou is even further from Gaizhou than Liaoyang, not to mention Anshan. The crux of the matter is that our numbers are insufficient. With a single brigade, two cavalry battalions, and less than a full artillery battalion, we barely muster six thousand men. If the Jianzhou deploy more than fifteen thousand, Haizhou will certainly be indefensible. Furthermore, our artillery ammunition is running low; we never anticipated having to make a desperate stand at Haizhou."

Dai Chunfeng attended the meeting as the representative of the General Staff. "Because of their limited numbers, the Jianzhou have not yet employed scaling ladders," he noted. "They are merely conducting probing attacks for now. Once their reinforcements arrive, and given our shortage of ammunition, Haizhou will be difficult to hold."

The other officers voiced their opinions, with the majority concluding that a desperate defense would not be cost-effective. They understood the core advantage of the Guards: their defensive prowess. Utilizing rudimentary fortifications, they could hold off an enemy half again their size, and behind sturdy city walls, they could face twice their number. However, if the numerical disparity was too extreme, victory would be out of the question.

Lu Xiangsheng summarized the consensus: "Then we have no choice but to retreat. We shall execute a phased withdrawal—first to Tashanpu, then to Yaozhou Post, onward to Liluoguo, and finally back to Gaizhou. Now the question is, what shall we do with the supplies? There is no way we can transport everything."

The commanders thought of the mountains of grain and fodder that could not be carried away, feeling a deep reluctance. Finally, they decided to select the finest wheat to urgently bake into field rations, allowing each man a five-day supply. Before the retreat, they would feed the warhorses with the best grain, and upon departure, put a torch to everything that could burn, leaving the Jianzhou nothing more than a hollow shell of a city.

Lu Xiangsheng resolved to begin the retreat in three days. He dispatched men under the cover of night to break through the enemy's loose encirclement, ordering the First Brigade to mobilize in its entirety and rendezvous at Tashanpu.

At the same moment in Liaoyang, Nurhaci was flying into a rage. The occupation of Haizhou by the Ming army had initially seemed trivial, as the Ming could strike Haizhou from multiple directions. He had first assumed they were Ming forces coming from western Liaoning, but reports quickly poured in that Yaozhou and Gaizhou had also fallen. Although no news had yet arrived from Jinzhou and Fuzhou, the map made it clear that those two places were likely facing a grim fate as well.

He had ordered Yoto to attack Haizhou, yet after all this time, no word of victory had come. To make matters worse, reports arrived from Jinzhou and Fuzhou: Liu Xingzuo (Liu Aita) had defected to the enemy, and he was joined by Li Yongfang's eldest son, Li Zenggeng.

Liu Aita had defected to Nurhaci in the thirty-third year of the Wanli era. Nurhaci had always trusted him, treating him almost like a son-in-law and appointing him as the regional commander administering the Four Southern Garrisons. Yet, he had actually defected!

As for Li Yongfang, he had surrendered to Nurhaci in the forty-format year of Wanli. Nurhaci had given him the daughter of Beile Abatai as a wife. During the campaigns to capture Qinghe, Tieling, Liaoyang, and Shenyang, he had been awarded the rank of regional commander for his meritorious service. And now, his eldest son had defected as well!

The fury in the Old Khan's heart was indescribable. He vented his anger by having three bondservants beaten to death on a pretext, which calmed him only slightly. He immediately sent men to summon Li Yongfang; he intended to demand why his eldest son had turned traitor.

Li Yongfang had already received word of his eldest son's defection to the Ming. When Nurhaci's messengers came for him, he knew disaster was imminent, yet he was utterly helpless. As the first general to surrender to Later Jin, even if he were to defect back now, the Ming court would never forgive him. Moreover, unlike Liu Xingzuo, his entire family—wives, children, and elderly relatives—were all in Liaoyang; he had no way to escape alone.

Upon entering Nurhaci's presence, Li Yongfang immediately dropped to his knees and kowtowed. "This slave has failed to properly instruct his son; I beg the Great Khan for punishment." Normally, Han military commanders did not style themselves as "slaves," but Li Yongfang hoped to move Nurhaci with emotion, reminding him of past services so that the punishment might be slightly lessened.

Nurhaci asked with a dark, gloomy expression, "Why did Zenggeng defect?"

Li Yongfang weighed his words carefully. "Great Khan, Liu Aita must have coerced my son. My son has always been utterly loyal to the Great Khan; he would never defect of his own accord."

He only knew that his son had defected, unaware of the specific circumstances. However, the Later Jin spies had reported the full details to Nurhaci. Furious, Nurhaci roared, "Guards, bind this traitor!"

Two white-armored soldiers immediately ripped off Li Yongfang's hat and tied him up with ropes. Brandishing a whip, Nurhaci lashed Li Yongfang across the face, instantly leaving a bloody welt.

Striking him again and again, Nurhaci cursed, "He strapped thorns to his back, wore a straw auction marker, and begged for his life on his knees, yet you claim Liu Aita coerced him! You father and son harbored the intent to return to the Ming court all along, which is why he defected!"

Li Yongfang clenched his jaw, terrified of further provoking Nurhaci, and remained utterly silent. This only enraged Nurhaci further. Striking him with even greater force, the Khan continued his tirade: "I know you Han people look down on me, viewing me as a barbarian. If Fushun had not been on the verge of falling back then, you would never have surrendered to me. You were once nothing more than a minor guerrilla commander; I had you marry a woman of the imperial lineage, I made you a regional commander, yet you remain a dog that cannot be truly tamed. The moment your former master beckons, you abandon me without a second thought. I will beat you to death, you treacherous dog!"

As he whipped the man, Nurhaci began to weep. He had treated the Han people with such immense generosity; Liu Aita had stayed for nearly twenty years only to run back, and Li Yongfang, a royal son-in-law, had watched his own eldest son run back as well. Was the ideological chasm between the civilized and the barbarian truly so insurmountable? Would he, a barbarian, forever remain a barbarian in their eyes?

Weeping as he struck, he was eventually left with only a single phrase: "I know you look down on me."

Li Yongfang dared neither argue nor dodge, and was on the verge of losing consciousness from the beating.

At that moment, Hong Taiji and Manggultai rushed in upon hearing the news. Not daring to stop Nurhaci directly, they called out from the side, "Father Khan, Son-in-Law Li is about to die!"

Nurhaci delivered a few more lashes before finally stopping. By then, Li Yongfang had fainted right on cue.

Having vented his fury, Nurhaci felt somewhat relieved. He said to Hong Taiji and Manggultai, "Let the Plain White and Plain Blue Banners each dispatch fifteen niru. You must capture Haizhou, annihilate the Ming army, and drag Liu Aita and Li Zenggeng back to me. I will have them sliced to pieces in a slow execution."