Chapter 120: Behind the Death of Tuohuan

The Enlightened Emperor Swordmaster Manor 2928 words 2026-03-24 19:31:32

Chapter 120: Behind the Death of Toghon

Zhu Qizhen immediately summoned Ma Shun.

Ma Shun had been prepared for this; he knew that given the current situation, Zhu Qizhen would inevitably call for him. Within moments, Ma Shun arrived. Without waiting for the Emperor to ask, he had already compiled a summary of all the intelligence he possessed regarding the Oirat.

"Your Majesty, because of the previous purge of Atai Khan, our intelligence network within the Oirat suffered heavy losses. Regarding this matter, I cannot yet provide a clear picture," Ma Shun reported. "However, based on the intelligence I have gathered, before Toghon died, he had been brewing the intention to replace the Golden Family and ascend the throne as Khan."

Zhu Qizhen frowned upon hearing this. "Ascend the throne as Khan? Did he take any action?"

Zhu Qizhen understood the prestige of the Golden Family on the grasslands all too well. While the Oirat were formidable now, without the veneer of the Golden Family, the various Mongol tribes would not necessarily submit to Toghon. Yet, it was perfectly natural for Toghon to harbor such ambitions. Zhu Qizhen had seen the internal contradictions of the Oirat at first glance years ago, and he realized now that he had understood much of it all along.

For instance, why had Toghon tolerated Atai Khan’s activity in the northwest without launching a massive campaign? It likely wasn't just because of the Ming Dynasty; rather, Toghon wanted to use Atai Khan to keep Tōtō-Bugha in check. As long as Atai Khan lived, Tōtō-Bugha’s prestige remained flawed. Tōtō-Bugha and Toghon needed each other. But once Atai Khan died, the honeymoon period between them would end. No Mongol Khan was content to be a puppet, especially since the Golden Family had deep roots in the grasslands, and not everyone was satisfied with an Oirat man wielding supreme power over the Mongols. Thus, Tōtō-Bugha could easily rally supporters. Toghon’s primary enemy had shifted from Atai Khan to Tōtō-Bugha.

"No wonder," Zhu Qizhen mused to himself, then asked, "What exactly happened with Toghon’s death? Was it natural, or was there foul play?"

"I deserve death, Your Majesty, but this matter is truly impossible to verify," Ma Shun replied.

Zhu Qizhen understood the gravity of the situation and said, "Forget it, no need to investigate further." He silently calculated the timeline. Toghon had come to power following the Battle of Hulunhuo in the twelfth year of the Yongle era, where Emperor Taizong had shattered the main Oirat force, causing Toghon’s father, Mahamud, to flee. Later, while the Oirat were still reeling, Arugtai had attacked and dealt them a crushing defeat. In the fourteenth year of Yongle, Mahamud died; legends of his death varied, with some claiming he died in battle and others citing internal strife. Regardless, after Mahamud’s death, Toghon had ascended.

Toghon had taken command at a critical moment and became the restorer of the Oirat. His first strategic decision was to request a title from the Ming, inheriting his father’s title, Prince of Shunning. In a sense, Toghon was a Prince of the Ming—though one who was neither submissive nor peaceful. From the fourteenth year of Yongle to the fourth year of Zhengtong, he had governed for over twenty years, leaving behind a vast empire. The only thing he wanted to do but failed to achieve was likely transforming the grasslands from Borjigin to Choros. Regardless of whether he succeeded, the legacy of that ambition would inevitably leave complications.

Zhu Qizhen asked, "Has the situation in Mongolia changed since Toghon’s death?"

"Although the atmosphere is tense, there has been no major war," Ma Shun replied. "Toghon’s son, Esen, has inherited his followers and power. However, Esen is not Toghon. His relationship with Tōtō-Bugha has eased somewhat, and Tōtō-Bugha has even gathered his own followers."

Zhu Qizhen felt a hint of disappointment. From his perspective, he would have loved to see Esen and Tōtō-Bugha clash, but he knew that was unrealistic. The most practical path for Esen was to consolidate his own position, and Tōtō-Bugha dared not push the Oirat faction too far. Both sides knew when to stop. Yet, this was not an end, but a new beginning.

Noticing the Emperor’s silence, Ma Shun guessed the Emperor was considering a move against the Oirat, especially given the ongoing, high-profile campaign in Luchuan. It was impossible for the Jinyiwei to be unaware of the Emperor's thoughts.

"Your Majesty," Ma Shun continued, "there is no need to worry about the Oirat for the time being. Esen is not Toghon. With Toghon gone, the various tribes on the grasslands are restless. I have heard that Hami, the northwestern Mongol tribes, and the Three Guards of Duoyan all have their own agendas. It will likely take Esen several years to securely establish his position as Grand Preceptor and Prince of Huai."

*Several years,* Zhu Qizhen thought. On the grasslands, unlike the orderly succession of the Central Plains, every hero’s influence was limited to his own person. The tribes obeyed the Oirat because they obeyed Toghon, not because they obeyed Esen. To build his own prestige, Esen had only one method: war. Moreover, Zhu Qizhen understood the realities of warfare in this era; simply traversing the vast Mongol territories, let alone campaigning, could take years. It would not be easy for Esen to suppress these tribes.

"Very well," Zhu Qizhen said. "Once the Luchuan campaign is settled, we shall see who is superior." Had it not been for the Luchuan war, he might have taken action in the grasslands—not a major offensive, but rather an effort to court those tribes unwilling to submit to the Oirat. This was, in fact, an old tactic of the Ming. Since the reign of the Founding Emperor, with the exception of the Jianwen Emperor, every successive monarch had followed the tradition of recruiting Mongol officials; there were many Mongol figures among the Ming nobility. These men were recruited through exactly such means. Many Mongols remained loyal to the Ming court even until the end of the dynasty; for instance, Man Gui, who died fighting outside the walls of Beijing, was a Mongol.

But for now, the bigger picture took precedence. Even without committing the troops of the Nine Garrisons, the sheer drain on national strength from the Luchuan campaign made it a rational decision for Zhu Qizhen to maintain peace with the Oirat.

"There is one more matter, Your Majesty," Ma Shun said, his expression darkening. "Regarding the losses in our Oirat intelligence network—I suspect there is a Mongol spy in the capital. No, I suspect there is one within the Eastern Depot."

Zhu Qizhen’s first reaction was that Ma Shun and Jin Ying were bickering again. The relationship between the Jinyiwei and the Eastern Depot was strained, particularly because they had different patrons, and the feud between Wang Zhen and Jin Ying had extended to their respective organizations. They had sabotaged each other many times before, but this was the first time such an accusation had been made. Zhu Qizhen felt that if neither the Jinyiwei nor the Eastern Depot could be trusted, then there was no one left in the world he could rely on. After all, both were inextricably tied to the imperial family.

Not wishing to speak too directly, he asked calmly, "Is there evidence?"

"I have none," Ma Shun admitted. "But I have spent years painstakingly planting assets in the Oirat. Even though many were not activated for this operation, they were still discovered by the Oirat. This is not normal."

Zhu Qizhen wondered if the Oirat had developed a counter-intelligence agency. "Could it be that the Oirat discovered the clues long ago and simply waited? Could those they captured have turned traitor?"

Ma Shun was alarmed. "Your Majesty, I can guarantee that my men are loyal to the Ming."

Zhu Qizhen waved a hand. "I do not doubt the loyalty of the Jinyiwei to me. I only doubt how long anyone can hold out under torture." He continued, "All missing personnel shall be treated as having died for the cause. The pensions due to them shall be generous, not a cent less. Regardless, we must investigate whether the Oirat have a specialized counter-intelligence unit. It may be that Toghon, before he died, was merely cleaning house for his son."

Ma Shun was left speechless. While this line of reasoning was plausible, he still felt something was amiss. But Zhu Qizhen had no interest in further discussion and waved for Ma Shun to withdraw.

*The Jinyiwei has suffered heavy losses; they must be placated,* Zhu Qizhen thought, deciding to reward Ma Shun—one could not let those who worked for the state suffer. As for the situation in the Eastern Depot, he pushed it to the back of his mind.